Should A Woman Having Twins Have A Home Birth Or Hospital Birth?

Views 2586

Should A Woman Having Twins Have A Home Birth Or Hospital Birth?

When twins are diagnosed before labor, both twins are head down and full term and delivered within 15 minutes of each other, attended home birth is as safe as hospital birth.

Knowing before labor that if you are carrying twins and whether the twins are in the same sac and whether twin A is vertex or breech can prevent the death of about 5% of twins around the time of birth, while 95% survive without this screening. The use of cesarean where indicated and delivering the second twin within 15 minutes of the first at vaginal twin birth prevents most perinatal mortality and morbidity. In order for a woman to base her decision for where and when to give birth based on expected survival rates, she would need to undergo an ultrasound at 36 weeks determining if she is having twins, if twin A is breech and whether the twins are in the same sac. 50% of twins at term are both vertex, 40% have one breech, and 8% both are breech. 

When to Deliver?

Gestational age of twins is the primary predictor of perinatal morbidity/mortality, with perinatal mortality lowest at 38 weeks. Just as singleton stillbirth rates increase from 1/1000 to 2/1000 after 42 weeks, the rate of unexplained stillbirths increase in twins increases after 37 weeks with rates of about 1/200 (0.5%) every week after that (Algert et. al. 2009) However in most cases, cesarean at or before 38 weeks does not improve outcomes over expectant management. (Dias and Akolekar, 2013)

Expedient delivery of the second twin within 15 minutes of the first twin saves Twin B's. (Leung 2002) Whatever the position of the first twin, the second twin is at risk of anoxia at vaginal birth after the delivery of the first twin because both placentas frequently separate immediately after the first twin is born. Therefore, it will always benefit twin survival rates to deliver the second twin within 15 minutes of the first.

When 30 minutes or more passes between the births of the twins, 25% of second twins have a pH of 7 or less. The outcomes of infants born with a pH of 7 or less is improved by neonatologist care in hospital. For those born in hospital with pH of 7 or less, long term morbidity occurs only in babies with additional problems. (Hafström 2012) There is no research on the long term outcomes of babies born with low pH at home. A second reason to expedite the delivery of the second twin is that after the birth of the first the cervix closes up in about 10 minutes. If the woman does not know she is having twins, no effort will be made to deliver the second twin expediently. The increased death and morbidity for Twin B due to placental separation is eliminated if Twin B is delivered within 15 minutes of Twin A. (Schmitz et. al. 2008)

How to Deliver? Cesarean or Vaginal?

At term, the overall death rate for low risk singleton births at home or in hospital is the same as for term twin births in hospital when both twins are head down in hospital: slightly less than 1/1000. (Rossi 2011)

However, when the first twin is breech, footling, frank or complete and the birth is a planned vaginal birth, the death rate ranges from 3/1000 (0.3%) – 10/1000 (1%). These deaths often involve cord prolapse (10/1000) and locked twins (2/1000). Twins have an increased risk of cord prolapse where breech, hydramnios, and preterm delivery complicate the birth.(Kahana 2004) When the first twin is frank breech, survival rates of attempted vaginal births are 99% under conditions in which 50% underwent emergency cesarean rates during labor (Sentilhes et. al. 2007)

At term, cesarean improves outcomes of locked twins. Locked twins occurs when the first twin is breech and the second is vertex. The incidence of locked twins in is about 1:500 twin pregnancies and about 1:68 with growth retarded twins in breech-vertex position (Haest et. al. 2005)

Monochorionic (in the same sac) vs Dichorionic (in different sacs)

One report of 1175 sets of twins at 36 weeks found 90% of twins in separate sacs (dichorionic) and 10% of twins in the same sac (monochorionic) (Hoffman et al 2012) Monochorionic sets of twins have higher stillbirth rates- one study found about 5% after 24 weeks where as 1.1% stillbirth rates after 24 weeks for dichorionic twins. (Ward et al. 2006) As Marion McLean reported in the Winter 2013 issue of Midwifery Today, between 80% - 95% of twins in the same sac survive when they are born by cesarean at 36 weeks. But in the absence of ultrasound, revealing whether the twins are in the same sac, less monochorionic twins survive. The outcomes of twins in the same sac appear to depend on gestational age at delivery, (Weisz et al 2012) Vaginal birth is possible, but optimal outcomes are associated with 65% cesarean birth rates (Weisz et al 2012)

Where to Deliver? Home or Hospital?

At home birth in the UK 2002-2005, where homebirth is supported by the National Health Service there were 7 deaths among 50 sets of twins at homebirths or 7% of twins (70/1000) died at attended term twin homebirths. (Symon et al. 2009)

At planned attended homebirths in Oregon in 2012, 2 twins died among 13 sets of twins (2/26) among a total of 1,249 births or 7.7% of twins died at birth according to this Oregon Birth Outcomes, by Planned Birth Place and Attendant report.  

Ina May Gaskin reports in Ina May's Guide to Childbirth (2003) on 2000 home births, with 8 perinatal deaths, including 15 sets of twins, but does not specifically report if any of the deaths involved the twin births.

Why Would a Woman Choose a Twin Homebirth?

The above information provides women with the opportunity to make informed choices and can be used by midwives to provide women with statistics. Women choose to have twins at home for many reasons. A big reason why women "choose" home birth for twins is because it is the only way they can access support for non-surgical birth. It is not uncommon for doctors and/or hospitals to refuse to support vaginal twin birth A homebirth midwife is sometimes the only practitioner with the skills to safely deliver twins vaginally.

The evidence shows that where the babies are both head down, and the pregnancy straightforward, and the twins delivered within 15 minutes of each other, there is no increased risk to the twins to be born at home. Breech birth risks can be decreased by delivering into hot water.

Elective Cesarean statistically improves perinatal outcomes but not maternal outcomes when performed for the following reasons: First twin in breech position (especially at first births), history of caesarean section; fetal distress; antepartum bleeding; pre-eclampsia and umbilical cord prolapse (Haest 2005). 

Among 758 sets of twins in France where Twin A was head down and > 35 weeks no deaths were documented with a 34% cesarean rate. (Schmitz 2008). Vaginal delivery was proposed to 657 women with first twin vertex including monoamniotic twins as long as they had clinically normal pelvis without past history of cesarean, the second twin was not 25% larger than the first twin, and umbilical artery blood flows and fetal heart rates were normal.

78% delivered vaginally and 21% had a cesarean during labor and 3 (0.5%) women had a cesarean for the second twin, and no twins died. In this study, when the first twin was vertex, the second twin was usually extracted manually by total breech extraction and the placentas were always extracted manually.

Elective cesarean was only done in cases of previous cesarean, placenta previa, IUGR, twin to twin transfusion and preeclampsia. In the vaginal delivery group more babies had an apgar <4 or apgar <7 at 5 minutes, but the difference was not significant. The planned vaginal births had less transfusions and less hysterectomies. This study shows that with careful selection for vaginal twin birth and expedient management, perinatal death of twins can be avoided. The authors are strongly opposed to routine cesarean for twins and conclude that for select patients with first twin presenting head first, planned vaginal delivery in hospital remains a safe option where active management of the second twin is routine.

How To

Once the decision is made to have a twin homebirth, the midwife needs to bring 2 cord cutting sets and extra receiving blankets. One possible way to remember which twin delivered first is to have one clamp pre-marked with red indelible ink and use it to clamp the cord of Twin A. If the second twin is breech, outcomes are better delivering it breech than to attempt to turn it. Breech birth outcomes are vastly improved by delivering breech into hot water because the cord continues to pulse in hot water as if it were still inside the womb for the minute until the head is delivered.

The best way to deliver the second twin before the cervix closes and/or the placenta separates is to start pushing out the second fetus 5 minutes after the first twin delivers, often in squatting, without a contraction. Both placentas deliver with or directly after the second twin. Don't pull on the cords because it might detach the placenta of the second fetus. If the cord is so short that it is impossible not to pull on it, it is better to cut it.

While at singleton births, only about 4% of women require a uterotonic to assist with contracting the uterus to prevent postpartum hemorrhage, after twins, closer to 50% profit from a shot of methergine 0.2mg IM to prevent postpartum hemorrhage. Sometimes a double dose or 0.4 mg methergine will be needed.


Algert CS, Morris JM, Bowen JR, Giles W, Roberts CL. Twin deliveries and place of birth in NSW 2001-2005. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol. 2009;49(5):461-6.

Dias T, Akolekar R. Timing of birth in multiple pregnancy. Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol. 2013 Dec 3. pii: S1521-6934(13)00152-1.

Haest KM, Roumen FJ, Nijhuis JG. Neonatal and maternal outcomes in twin gestations > or =32 weeks according to the planned mode of delivery. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol. 2005 1;123(1):17-21.

Hoffmann E, Oldenburg A, Rode L, Tabor A, Rasmussen S, Skibsted L. Twin births: cesarean section or vaginal delivery? Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2012;91(4):463-9.

Hafström M, Ehnberg S, Blad S, Norén H, Renman C, Rosén KG, Kjellmer I. Developmental outcome at 6.5 years after acidosis in term newborns: a population-based study. Pediatrics. 2012;129(6):e1501-7.

Kahana B, Sheiner E, Levy A, Lazer S, Mazor M. Umbilical cord prolapse and perinatal outcomes. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2004;84(2):127-32.

Leung TY, Tam WH, Leung TN, Lok IH, Lau TK. Effect of twin-to-twin delivery interval on umbilical cord blood gas in the second twins. BJOG 2002;109:63–7.

Rossi AC, Mullin PM, Chmait RH. Neonatal outcomes of twins according to birth order, presentation and mode of delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BJOG. 2011;118(5):523-32.

Schmitz T, Carnavalet Cde C, Azria E, Lopez E, Cabrol D, Goffinet F. Neonatal outcomes of twin pregnancy according to the planned mode of delivery. Obstet Gynecol. 2008;111(3):695-703.

Sentilhes L, Goffinet F, Talbot A, Diguet A, Verspyck E, Cabrol D, Marpeau L. Attempted vaginal versus planned cesarean delivery in 195 breech first twin pregnancies. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2007;86(1):55-60.

Symon A, Winter C, Inkster M, Donnan PT. Outcomes for births booked under an independent midwife and births in NHS maternity units: matched comparison study.BMJ. 2009;338:b2060.

Ward Platt MP, Glinianaia SV, Rankin J, Wright C, Renwick M. The North of England Multiple Pregnancy Register: five-year results of data collection. Twin Res Hum Genet. 2006;9(6):913-8.

Weisz B, Hogen L, Yinon Y, Mazaki S, Gindes L, Schiff E, Lipitz S. Mode of delivery and neonatal outcome in uncomplicated monochorionic twin pregnancies. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2012;25(12):2721-4.

Disclaimer: This article is not intended to provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Views expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of GreenMedInfo or its staff.

Key Research Topics

This website is for information purposes only. By providing the information contained herein we are not diagnosing, treating, curing, mitigating, or preventing any type of disease or medical condition. Before beginning any type of natural, integrative or conventional treatment regimen, it is advisable to seek the advice of a licensed healthcare professional.

© Copyright 2008-2024, Journal Articles copyright of original owners, MeSH copyright NLM.